How much does it cost to hire James for a medical malpractice case?

Cost depends on the type of matter, the fee model (contingency, flat, hourly), and how contested the case becomes. James walks through the likely range during the consult so there are no surprises.

Does James offer a free consultation?

James charges for the initial consult; that fee is credited toward representation if you retain James's office. Some medical malpractice attorneys offer free consults — check James's current terms during booking.

How long do medical malpractice cases in New York typically take?

Simple medical malpractice matters can wrap in a few weeks; disputed cases can run 6–18 months from intake to resolution, longer if the matter goes to trial. James gives a realistic estimate for your facts at the consult — vague answers here are a red flag.

Can James take my case if I'm outside Woodbury?

James is licensed in New York. Matters governed by New York law are the natural fit. Out-of-state matters are handled case-by-case, sometimes with local co-counsel. Ask during intake — James will tell you if the case is a fit or refer you to someone closer to your court.

What should I bring to my first meeting with James?

Bring every document that touches the dispute: contracts, correspondence, police or medical reports, filed pleadings, invoices, photographs, insurance letters. Also bring a written timeline of what happened, in your own words. James will filter what matters — over-preparing at intake is always cheaper than needing a second meeting.

Is James accepting new medical malpractice clients right now?

James's intake status shifts week to week. Submit the form; the office will confirm availability or refer the matter out.

Unclaimed · Is this you?

James S. McCarthy, Medical Malpractice Attorney in Woodbury, New York

Over 34 years of legal practice · focused on Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury

PartneratButtafuoco & Associates

Woodbury New, NY

Practicing medical malpractice in Woodbury since 1992.

34+: Years practicing
1: Bar admission

Practices in

Medical Malpractice Personal Injury

Are you James S. McCarthy?

This profile was built from public bar records and is still unclaimed. Claim it free to control your photo, bio, and fees — and get client inquiries sent straight to you.

Claim this profile — free

Quick answer

James S. McCarthy is a partner based in Woodbury, NY. The practice focuses on Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury. James has over 34 years of legal experience. Currently practicing at Buttafuoco & Associates.

Based in: Woodbury, NY
Experience: over 34 years
Known for: Medical Malpractice · Personal Injury

Handles Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury matters from Woodbury, NY.
Over 34 years of practice as a licensed attorney.

Areas of practice

Legal matters James takes on

James concentrates on medical malpractice and personal injury. Each area below outlines the kind of case James handles, typical outcomes to expect, and how the intake process starts.

Medical Malpractice cases in Woodbury, New York

James takes medical malpractice matters in Woodbury, New York. Typical engagements include intake calls to scope the issue, review of any records or filings you already have, and a written strategy memo before James agrees to represent you.

Personal Injury cases in Woodbury, New York

James takes personal injury matters in Woodbury, New York. Typical engagements include intake calls to scope the issue, review of any records or filings you already have, and a written strategy memo before James agrees to represent you.

Biography

Meet James S. McCarthy — medical malpractice lawyer in Woodbury

James joined Daniel P.Buttafuoco and Associates as a trial lawyer in 1991 and has tried and litigated many significant medical malpractice, automobile, premises, products liability and construction accident cases. James focuses his practice on the litigation and trial of medical malpractice cases. He has extensive experience in handling all aspects of such cases from initial investigation of potential claims through to trial. Over the years James has obtained millions of dollars for victims of birth injuries, wrongful death, untimely diagnosed cancer, surgical injuries and brain damage caused by physicians’ negligence.

From the inception of the case until closing arguments, he zealously fights for the rights of his clients in order to obtain maximum compensation either through settlement or verdict. Given that many of the cases James handles involve wrongful death or total incapacitation, he has extensive experience in all Surrogate Court matters. Unlike many personal injury firms who refer clients to outside Surrogate Court attorneys, James handles all related Surrogate Court matters personally. This saves clients considerable time and money. In a recent case, James obtained a favorable settlement immediately prior to trial for a child who suffered cerebral palsy as a result of obstetrical malpractice. After settlement, a Supplemental Needs Trust was created in order to allow the infant to continue to obtain Medicaid for her disabilities, while retaining all settlement proceeds in a special trust.

James was admitted to the New York State Bar Association in February 1992 and the United States Federal Courts in July 1992. He is a member of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association and the Suffolk County Bar Association.

James's approach to medical malpractice cases

James graduated cum laude in 1991 with a Juris Doctor degree from Touro College Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center in Huntington, NY after earning his B.A. in political Science from the State University of New York at Stony Brook in Stony Brook, NY. James joined Daniel P.Buttafuoco and Associates as a trial lawyer in 1991 and has tried and litigated many significant medical malpractice, automobile,…

The kind of cases James takes

James reviews new inquiries case-by-case for medical malpractice and personal injury matters in Woodbury and the surrounding New York area.

Credentials

Education, bar admissions, and languages

Touro Law School
J.D. · 1991
State University New York at Stony Brook
—

Jurisdictions

James's state bar admissions

New York
1992 · ACTIVE

James studied at J.D. in Touro Law School and — in State University New York at Stony Brook.

Law school and academic background

James completed J.D. in Touro Law School and — in State University New York at Stony Brook. Formal legal training is one signal of substantive knowledge — the day-to-day practice James runs in New York is where that training gets applied to real client questions.

Locations

James S. McCarthy's office in Woodbury

James's primary office is at 144 Woodbury Rd., Woodbury, NY, 11797. In-person meetings are by appointment; a phone intake usually comes first.

Main office

Buttafuoco & Associates

144 Woodbury Rd.

Woodbury, NY 11797

Open in Google Maps

Client feedback

Client reviews of James S. McCarthy

James has not yet collected verified client reviews on LawyersListed. Reviews here are all from confirmed clients; anonymous ratings are moderated out.

No reviews yet

Only verified clients who have consulted with James S. McCarthy can leave a review.

Schedule your consultation

Hiring guide

How to hire James S. McCarthy — what to expect in your first consultation

Working with a new medical malpractice attorney should feel structured. Here's how the first two conversations with James usually go, from the moment you request a consult to the day representation begins.

Consultation formats and pricing

James charges for the initial consult. That fee is credited toward representation if you retain James's office.

What to bring to your first meeting

Bring any documents you already have — police reports, medical records, filed pleadings, correspondence from an insurer, a copy of the contract at issue. If you're not sure, err on the side of bringing everything; James will tell you what matters and what doesn't.

Questions to ask a medical malpractice attorney in Woodbury, New York

A short list to run through before you commit: How many medical malpractice matters have you handled in the last year? What's your fee structure? Who else in the office will work on this? What's your realistic estimate of timeline and range of outcomes? How do I reach you between meetings?

Fees & payment

Fees, payment methods, and consultation options for James

James discusses fees during intake so the arrangement fits the matter. Contingency, hourly, and flat-fee options are all common in medical malpractice practice — ask which fits.

Hourly rates, contingency fees, and flat-fee options

Every medical malpractice matter is priced differently. Simple document review might be a flat fee. Injury litigation is often contingency. Complex commercial disputes usually run hourly with a retainer. James confirms the model in the engagement letter before any work starts.

Payment methods and payment plans

James's office accepts standard payment methods. Ask about payment plans if the retainer is a stretch — many medical malpractice practices work with clients on structured schedules.

Frequently asked

Frequently asked questions about James S. McCarthy

How much does it cost to hire James for a medical malpractice case?
Cost depends on the type of matter, the fee model (contingency, flat, hourly), and how contested the case becomes. James walks through the likely range during the consult so there are no surprises.
Does James offer a free consultation?
James charges for the initial consult; that fee is credited toward representation if you retain James's office. Some medical malpractice attorneys offer free consults — check James's current terms during booking.
How long do medical malpractice cases in New York typically take?
Simple medical malpractice matters can wrap in a few weeks; disputed cases can run 6–18 months from intake to resolution, longer if the matter goes to trial. James gives a realistic estimate for your facts at the consult — vague answers here are a red flag.
Can James take my case if I'm outside Woodbury?
James is licensed in New York. Matters governed by New York law are the natural fit. Out-of-state matters are handled case-by-case, sometimes with local co-counsel. Ask during intake — James will tell you if the case is a fit or refer you to someone closer to your court.
What should I bring to my first meeting with James?
Bring every document that touches the dispute: contracts, correspondence, police or medical reports, filed pleadings, invoices, photographs, insurance letters. Also bring a written timeline of what happened, in your own words. James will filter what matters — over-preparing at intake is always cheaper than needing a second meeting.
Is James accepting new medical malpractice clients right now?
James's intake status shifts week to week. Submit the form; the office will confirm availability or refer the matter out.

Areas served

Medical Malpractice attorneys serving Woodbury and Albany in New York

James handles medical malpractice matters throughout New York. Each city below is a direct link into the search page for verified medical malpractice attorneys in that community.

More counsel

If James's intake is full or the fit isn't right, these medical malpractice attorneys in Woodbury handle similar matters. Every profile below is verified and open to consultations.